This was my first time workshopping and critiquing other
people’s work in an open environment. I actually enjoyed the whole process very
thoroughly, especially the part when the writer had to be mute the whole time
he/she was being criticized. I believe this workshop process made everyone of
us open minded towards criticism and taught us to accept and appreciate
criticism the way we tend to accept compliments. Before this workshop, I never
really enjoyed reading poetry or even writing it. I thought writing poetry was
one the hardest form of writing. But this class, and especially doing workshops
made me love reading other people’s poems and even writing my own. Most of the
poems I wrote during this process was solely based on my personal experience,
which made it easier for me to write about my emotions, thoughts and opinions.
The criticism and compliments that I got for my poem from my fellow classmates
and professors really helped me to revise and write a better form of it. I
really can’t think of any draw backs, from the workshop process. I think this
method really works for rising poets and writers to be open to criticism,
compliments, judgments, confrontation, and much more. Poetry is very creative,
and sometimes the readers may not quite understand what the poet is trying to
convey through those detailed imagery, or even not using any imagery at all.
Thus poetry is very subjective, as the audience can only analyze and criticize
what is written in front of them, and trying to think outside of the box which
sometimes works very nicely and other times its literally redundant and painful.
Even with these certain flaws, I think talking about poems and discussing it in
front of the writer, lets the writer know what is their writing is actually
portraying towards other people. Thus it can be very helpful for them to change
and revise their work, or leave it as they have written it already.
I really like that you focus on the poet remaining silent during workshop. I think this is one of the most important parts of workshop because it allows the poem to stand entirely on its own and keeps intentions out of the picture. I think workshop is such a positive experience, even when it sucks.
ReplyDelete